Full text international journal of business and applied social. Similarities and differences between alderfers erg theory. He recategorized maslows hierarchy of needs into three simpler and broader classes of needs. Maslows idea of the needs being an active motivator is true and yes alderfer agreed but i believe that alderfer took it a step further. No, alderfer was not a physicist and erg in this case is not a unit of energy equal to 107 joules. Alderfer erg theory in management essay many essays. The existence group is concerned with providing the basic material existence requirements of humans.
The impact of motivation on aggregate resignation semantic scholar. Pdf this study utilized alderfers existence, relatedness, and growth erg theory of human needs as the basic framework to investigate consumer. Relevance of theories of motivation in retail business. Erg theory is a theory in psychology proposed by clayton alderfer. Alderfers research has indicated some degree of support. How the erg theory of motivation changes our perception of needs. Pdf an empirical study of the existence, relatedness, and growth. Maslow american psychologist born on september 1, 1940 attended yale. In a reaction to the famous hierarchy of needs by maslow, alderfer distinguishes three categories of human needs that influence workers behavior. The existence needs are satisfied by material incentives. Term paper on alderfers erg theory assignment motivation is thus a process of arousing and sustaining goaldirected behavior stimulated by the anticipations for satisfying individual necessities.
Erg theory groups human needs into three broad categories. Alderfers erg theory explains his behavioral processes. Pdf an alderfer perspective of the higher education restructuring. Douglas mcgregor proposed two distinct views of human beings. Alderfers erg theory is the extension of maslows needs hierarchy, wherein the maslows five needs are categorized into three categories, viz. Clayton alderfer, a psychologist, amended maslows hierarchy of needs to produce erg theory, which refers to existence, relatedness, and growth. The e, r and g of erg theory stand for existence, relatedness and growth the three sets of needs which are the focus of this alternative theory of human needs in organizations. Alderfers theory, by grouping together very different types of motivation, the. The erg theory does not offer clear cut guidelines. Both are content theories, the basic needs emphasized in both are the same, the overall structure of need categories is also the same.
It also acknowledges the fact that the specific combination of needs that must be fulfilled is specific to the individual. If need fulfillment at higher levels is fustrating we regress to fulfill lower level needs can be badtraditionally, various hr and organizational. Existence needs physiological and safety needs relatedness needs involvement. An american psychologist clayton paul alderfer had proposed this theory and believed that each need carries some value and hence. Pdf an alderfer perspective of the higher education. Employee needs and motivation boundless management. All about alderfers theory of human needs erg theory.
Taking a theory as wellknown as maslows hierarchy of needs and reinventing it is a bold move, but thats exactly what clayton alderfer did. In 1969, alderfer published a paper that was called an empirical test of a new theory of human need. He arranges the pyramid of human needs from specific needs to abstract needs into three basic. Existence, relatedness, growth erg theory of motivation. One basically negative called theory x and the other basically positive labeled theory y. Under theory x, the four assumptions held by managers are. Erg theory of motivation is the condensed form of maslows hierarchy of needs.
Clayton alderfer revised maslows hierarchy theory is known as erg theory. Understanding how maslow, alderfer and herzberg are interrelated. Although based on the famous work of maslow, it differs from maslows theory in three ways. Although alderfer does not disagree with maslows hierarchy of needs completely, he does not agree with all of them. In the words of frunzi, motivation is considered to be the process of satisfying internal. The theory was developed by clayton paul alderfer, an american psychologist, and consultant, between the 60s and the 70s, based on the empirical study conducted at a factory in easton, pennsylvania. Thursday i could have a half a day off on friday motivated me immensely. Theory of motivation was published by clayton paul alderfer as a further extension of maslows pyramid of needs.
Erg theory also shows that if the fulfilment of a higherlevel need is subdued, there is an increase in desire for satisfying a lowerlevel need. Both theories have similarities as well as differences on some important aspects. Aldefer is an american psychologist known for his further development of maslows hierarchy of needs theory in the erg theory existence is defined as the physiological. Argues, as maslow did, that people do have needs, that those needs are arranged in a hierarchy and that needs are important determinants. Erg theory is a theory of human needs and motivation by clayton p. The widest accepted explanation of the motivation was given by victor vroom 1964 with the theory most commonly known as the expectationvalue theory that tries to merge together the various elements of previous theories. But how will we determine which of the three needs is more important to that person. In other words, all students try their hardest, complete assignments on time, and seem eager to learn. An alderfer perspective of the higher education restructuring in south africa. Alderfers erg theory is a simplified version of maslows hierarchy of needs that suggests that all human needs can be accessed and satisfied simultaneously, rather than from the bottom up. Clayton paul alderfer september 1, 1940 october 30, 2015 was an american psychologist and consultant known for further developing maslows hierarchy of needs. Kogut and zanders theory of evolutionary theory versus internationalization theory.
According to maslow, an individual remains at a particular need level until that need is satisfied. Since the need hierarchy theory of abraham maslow is being the core of study, this theory is dealt in detail in chapter i11 separately. Currently consulting for 60 nonprofit organizations author of the egr theory erg. This is how we get the abbreviation erg it is a reflection of those needs. Get an answer for give an example of how the erg theory could be used to explain someones motivation to work in a job. This is based on similar needs as maslows theory, but emphasizes the fact that if higher tiers are not fulfilled then the demand for the fulfillment of lower tiers will increase. Alderfers erg theory alderfers erg theory builds on. Alderfer first presented the erg theory of motivation in 1969 in his article, an empirical test of a new theory of human need.
What are the similarities and differences between the erg. Maslows hierarchy of needs theory, herzbergs two factor theory and alderfers erg theory simons, 1987. Compare and contrast clayton paul alderfers erg theory of. Alderfers erg theory of motivation imagine a classroom where motivation is not an issue.
Alderfers erg theory, based on maslows hierarchy of needs, outlines three. This theory says that an individual can satisfy any of the three needs first. It suggests that people may have multiple active needs and may more up or down the hierarchy 2. Alderfer american psychologist introduced the erg theory in 1969 alderfers erg theory simplifies maslows hierarchy of needs alderfers erg theory contends there are. Well known process theories are vrooms expectancy theory, fourdrive theory, skinners reinforcement theory and adams equity theory12. Erg theory a theory of human motivationthat focuses on three groups of needs that form a hierarchy. Difference between maslow need hierarchy theory and alderfers erg theory erg theory states that at a given point of time, more than one need may be operational. Needs are physiological or psychological scarcities that stimulate behavior therefore are necessary to live a healthy, productive lives both in personal and work lives.
The erg theory existence, relatedness, growth is a rework of the maslows need hierarchy by clayton alderfer from yale university bethel, 2005. History of management theoryhuman relations movement. Alderfer believed that needs can be met simultaneously and in no. This theory is a new concept as compared to the maslows theory. Clayton alderfers erg theory of motivationphysical wellbelinginclude a persons physiological and physically related safety needs, such as the need for food, shelter, and safe working conditionscorrespond to maslows physiological and safety needs. Alderfer, in which he distinguishes three categories of human needs that influence workers behavior. The erg theory, proposed by clayton alderfer in 1969, seeks to rank human needs in a hierarchy. Existence needs corresponding to maslows physiological and safety needs include a persons physiological and physically related safety needs. Alderfer further developed maslows hierarchy of needs by categorizing the hierarchy into his erg theory existence, relatedness and growth. As the above figure shows, alderfer have divided human needs into three distinct.
Comparing maslow, alderfer, and mcclelland most theories of motivation revolve around the idea an employees needs influence their motivation. Alderfer has grouped further the five needs enunciated by maslow. S in industrial administration doctorate in organizational development still alive. Motivation process theories explore process of motivation specifications. The day to day operation of the college seems to run smoothly, however, from verbal interaction with colleagues it seems that although communication is constant. Erg theory also shows that if the fulfillment of a higherlevel need is subdued, there is an increase in desire for satisfying a. The existence needs combine the physiological and safety needs of maslows model. Alderfers theory of motivation, sometimes also threefactor theory or abbreviated erg existence, relatedness and growth is a theory dealing with the motivation of people. Similarities and dissimilarities between alderfers erg theory of motivation and maslows needs hierarchy are similarities. Evaluating the applicability of maslows theory of motivation to. The relationship that results from combining one thing with another. Existence needs these include need for basic material.
Born in sellersville, pennsylvania, alderfer obtained his ba in psychology in 1962 at yale university, where he also obtained his phd in psychology 1966. According to alderfer human needs can be grouped into three groups called existence, relatedness and growth needs. Erg theory was developed by clayton alderfer as a revision of abraham maslows hierarchy of needs. Erg theory of motivation to bring maslows need hierarchy theory of motivation in synchronization with empirical research, clayton alderfer redefined it in his own terms.
Alderfers erg theory free download as powerpoint presentation. The main difference between maslows needs hierarchy and. Alderfers erg theory builds on maslows hierarchy following ways. Existence needs, relatedness needs, and growth needs. A critical evaluation of maslow and erg theory business essay. The motivation theories of maslow hierarchy of needs, alderfer erg model and herzberg twofactor theory are closely related they can be linked and crossreferenced although each theory can challenge the others complete findings.
998 945 915 1045 1236 2 1327 465 1555 787 1266 1443 467 1270 643 634 475 904 633 199 1488 881 1269 328 646 137 345 1482 832 1361 176 498 967 1158